363x Filetype PPTX File size 1.26 MB Source: usuaris.tinet.cat
What do we know?
Translation and Language Learning, with Kirsten Malmkjaer and Mar
Gutiérrez. Luxembourg: European Commission, 2013.
- Questionnaire: 963 teachers and academics
- Additional submissions: 101
- Croatia, Finland, France, Germany, Poland, Spain, United Kingdom,
Australia, China, United States
Why not use translation?
- Translating is old-fashioned, used for classical languages.
- Translating is not communicative.
- Translating stops students from thinking in L2.
- Translating takes time away from more valuable learning activities.
- Translating is for professionals only.
Where are your students going?
- Language subject 1: 160 students.
- Language subject 3: 25 students.
- Language subject 5: 39 students.
- Language subject 7: 18 students
- Language subject 9: 6 students.
Why use translation?
- Translating is old-fashioned, used for classical languages.
- It can be used in many new ways, for any languages.
- Translating is not communicative.
- Don’t translators and interpreters communicate?
- Translating stops students from thinking in L2.
- Adult learners are thinking in L1 anyway.
- Translating takes time away from more valuable learning activities.
- Translating can teach many valuable things.
- Translating is for professionals only.
- It is one of the things that people actually do with a language, at all
levels.
How not to use translation
- To repeat in L2 everything that has been said in L1.
- To get students to give the one true correct translation.
- To get students spending hours going between texts in L1 and L2.
no reviews yet
Please Login to review.